The phrase "each of them has or have" presents a grammatical choice rooted in subject-verb agreement: "has" is correct when "each" is the subject, while "have" is incorrect unless the subject is plural.
"Each" is a singular pronoun meaning one individual from a group. When "each" leads a clause, the verb must agree with the singular subject. The construction "each of them" treats "each" as the grammatical subject, not "them."
For example: "Each of them has completed the assignment." Here, "each" is singular, so "has" is required. Using "have" would violate standard subject-verb agreement.
Subject-verb agreement requires matching the verb form to the number of the subject. "Each" always takes a singular verb, regardless of the plural noun that follows.
Consider: "Each of the students has submitted their report." Even though "students" is plural, the subject is "each," which is singular. Therefore, "has" is correct.
This rule applies even when the sentence structure is complex. For instance: "Each of the teams has won at least one game this season." The verb remains singular because "each" governs the agreement.
Many people incorrectly use "have" after "each of them" because they focus on the plural noun "them" rather than the singular subject "each."
Incorrect: "Each of them have the right to speak." Correct: "Each of them has the right to speak."
This error persists in spoken English and informal writing. However, formal writing and standardized tests require strict adherence to subject-verb agreement.
A common confusion arises when "each" appears in a compound subject. For example: "Each of the team members and the coach has signed the contract." Even with multiple entities, "each" remains singular.
In rare cases, especially in dialectal or conversational English, "have" may appear after "each of them" due to proximity to plural antecedents. This usage is nonstandard and should be avoided in formal contexts.
For example: "Each of them have their own keys." While this sounds natural in speech, it violates grammar rules. The correct version is: "Each of them has their own keys."
Some writers justify "have" by arguing that "them" is the logical subject. But grammar rules prioritize syntactic structure over semantic intent. "Each" is the grammatical subject, not "them."
Use the following table to clarify correct usage:
| Construction | Correct Verb | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Each of them has finished. | has | Singular subject: "each" |
| Each of them have finished. | ❌ Incorrect | Violates subject-verb agreement |
| Each of the books has a unique cover. | has | Subject is "each," not "books" |
| Each of the players has a jersey. | has | Plural noun doesn't affect verb choice |
Even in complex sentences, the rule holds. "Each of the applicants has submitted their application." The verb remains singular despite the plural noun "applicants."
The Associated Press Stylebook (2020) states: "Each is singular. Use a singular verb with each." This confirms that "has" is correct in formal writing.
Similarly, the Purdue Online Writing Lab (OWL) explains: "When 'each' is the subject, use a singular verb. Do not let the plural object confuse the verb choice."
These guidelines apply consistently across academic, journalistic, and technical writing. Deviating from them reduces clarity and credibility.
I once reviewed a college admissions essay where the student wrote: "Each of them have different goals." The sentence was flagged during proofreading. After correcting to "Each of them has different goals," the clarity improved. The original version sounded awkward and unprofessional.
Other indefinite pronouns follow the same rule. For example:
These pronouns are singular and take singular verbs. "Each" behaves identically.
There is no context in standard English where "each of them have" is grammatically correct. The word "each" demands a singular verb. Always use "has" with "each of them."
When in doubt, test the sentence by removing "of them." If "Each has..." sounds correct, then "Each of them has..." is correct. If "Each have..." sounds wrong, avoid it.
For further guidance on handling singular subjects in programming contexts, see python for each in list.