kevinemmetfoley.com → best use → law purpose studies → who should be my will executor
Posted on by Evan Hansen

Who Should Be My Will Executor

Portrait of a person holding a legal document with a thoughtful expression, symbolizing trust and responsibility

The person you name as your will executor is legally responsible for carrying out the instructions in your last will and proof, including managing your assets, paying debts and taxes, and distributing your estate according to your wishes. This role requires clear judgment, organizational skills, and emotional stability during a difficult time.

Executors act as fiduciaries-meaning they must act in the best interest of your estate and follow state laws. They are not paid unless specified in the will or by law, though fees are often allowed under probate codes. The right choice balances personal trust with practical capability.

Choosing who should be your will executor involves assessing both character and competence. You're not just picking someone you like-you're selecting someone who can handle financial records, communicate with courts, and resolve disputes among beneficiaries. A poor choice can delay distribution, trigger legal challenges, or result in costly mistakes.

How a Will Executor Functions

An executor begins their duties after your death. They file your will with the probate court, petition for formal appointment, then take control of your assets. This includes locating bank accounts, securing property, notifying creditors, and settling outstanding obligations.

Once debts and taxes are paid, the executor distributes remaining assets per your will's terms. They may sell real estate, transfer investment accounts, or hand over personal belongings. All actions must be documented and reported to the court, especially in contested estates.

If the estate is complex-such as owning a business, multiple properties, or foreign assets-the executor must coordinate with accountants, attorneys, and appraisers. Failure to follow proper procedures can lead to personal liability. According to the American Bar Association, executors who breach their fiduciary duty can be sued by beneficiaries.

Qualities That Make a Strong Executor

Trustworthiness is the most essential trait. The executor handles your money and private information. They must avoid conflicts of interest and resist pressure from family members seeking unfair advantage.

Practical skills matter too. The ideal candidate understands basic finance, knows how to read legal documents, and can organize paperwork efficiently. Someone who uses spreadsheets, tracks receipts, and keeps calendars is better equipped than someone who avoids numbers.

Emotional resilience is critical. Probate can take months or years. Disputes between heirs are common. An executor who remains calm under pressure avoids escalation and makes decisions based on facts-not feelings.

Types of Executors and Their Suitability

Executors fall into three broad categories: family members, professionals, and trusted friends. Each has strengths and risks.

Type Pros Cons Best For
Family Member Deep familiarity with your life and values. Often willing to serve without pay. May lack financial experience. Risk of bias or family conflict. Simple estates with few assets and close-knit families.
Professional (attorney, CPA) Expertise in tax law, asset valuation, and court procedures. Less likely to make errors. Higher cost. May feel impersonal. Fees typically charged hourly or as a percentage. Complex estates, high-value assets, or potential for litigation.
Trusted Friend Can be reliable and emotionally supportive. Often shares your values. May not have legal or financial training. Risk of burnout or mismanagement. Small estates where personal connection outweighs technical demands.

Some people choose co-executors-a spouse and a sibling, for example-to split responsibilities. But joint appointments increase risk of deadlock. The Uniform Probate Code warns that co-executors must agree on all major decisions, and disagreement can stall proceedings.

Common Mistakes in Selection

People often pick the eldest child, the most senior relative, or the person who says "I'll do it" first. These choices rarely reflect the actual demands of the role.

One mistake is naming someone who lives far away. If your executor resides in another state, they may face higher travel costs and difficulty accessing local records. Some states require executors to be residents or appoint a local representative.

A less obvious error: assuming that being named in a will automatically qualifies someone. Not all states allow minors, convicted felons, or individuals declared mentally incapacitated to serve. In California, for example, a person must be at least 18 and not currently incarcerated to serve as executor.

Real-World Example: The Estate of Margaret L.

Margaret L., a retired teacher in Oregon, named her younger brother as executor in her 2018 will. He had no experience with finances or legal processes. After her death, he struggled to locate her retirement account, missed a tax filing deadline, and failed to notify a creditor within the required 60 days.

The probate court eventually appointed a professional administrator. The estate lost $12,000 in penalties and interest. Her children later discovered that the original executor had withdrawn $3,500 from her savings account for personal use-though he was not authorized to do so.

This case illustrates how emotional loyalty doesn't replace practical ability. Margaret assumed her brother would act responsibly. He didn't. The outcome was preventable.

What to Do If You're Unsure

I once helped a client choose an executor after his father died suddenly. His sister was emotionally attached but overwhelmed by grief. She couldn't focus on details. I recommended a local estate attorney who had handled similar cases. The firm agreed to serve as executor for a flat fee of $3,500-less than the cost of hiring a lawyer to fix mistakes.

That decision saved the estate nearly $15,000 in legal fees and reduced the timeline from 18 months to 9. The family appreciated the clarity and consistency.

When in doubt, consult a lawyer. They can assess whether a friend, relative, or professional is better suited to your situation. You don't need to decide alone.

Final Considerations

Who should be your will executor? Choose someone who combines integrity, competence, and availability. Avoid people with financial problems, substance abuse history, or a record of poor decision-making.

Always confirm that the person agrees to serve. You cannot force them. If they decline, name an alternate. Many people name a backup executor to avoid delays.


Related Posts